The Pre-Season Rush: Why Luxury Buyers Didn't Wait for January at The Colony and Tiburón
    Back to BlogMarket Insights

    The Pre-Season Rush: Why Luxury Buyers Didn't Wait for January at The Colony and Tiburón

    November 17, 20266 min read
    Share

    Every fall, the conventional wisdom in Southwest Florida is the same: luxury buyers wait for January. They fly in for season, tour in February, and write offers in March.

    This fall, a lot of them didn't wait.

    We pulled every closed MLS sale in three private golf settings for the exact same 60-day window, September 18 through November 17, in 2025 and in 2026. Two of them lit up. The Colony at Pelican Landing went from 3 closings to 16. Tiburón in Naples went from 3 to 10. Together with the rest of Pelican Landing, these three settings closed $41.7 million in homes this fall, up from $23.1 million in the same weeks last year.

    The headline numbers

    Closed sales · Sep 18 – Nov 17

    2025 vs. 2026, same 60 days

    Dark bar = 2025 closings. Gold bar = 2026 closings.

    1. The Colony at Pelican Landing3 → 16

      Bonita Springs / Estero

      Volume $4.1M → $23.7M2026 median $1.39M
    2. Tiburón3 → 10

      Naples

      Volume $6.1M → $11.3M2026 median $1.23M
    3. Rest of Pelican Landing18 → 11

      Bonita Springs

      Volume $12.9M → $6.7M2026 median $492K
    Source: Julie Borden analysis of Southwest Florida MLS closed sales; residential sales over $50K, rentals excluded.
    • The Colony at Pelican Landing: 3 closings → 16. Sales volume rose from $4.1 million to $23.7 million. The median sale was $1,387,500, up from $1,220,000.
    • Tiburón (Naples): 3 closings → 10. Volume rose from $6.1 million to $11.3 million, and the median price per square foot rose from $509 to $557.
    • The rest of Pelican Landing: 18 closings → 11. The median sale here fell from $681,250 to $492,000.
    • All three together: 24 closings → 37, and $23.1 million → $41.7 million in volume.

    The Colony: the towers came alive

    The Colony is the high-rise and estate enclave inside Pelican Landing, with Gulf views from its towers and access to the Colony Golf & Bay Club. Of its 16 fall closings, 10 were in mid- and high-rise buildings and 6 were single-family homes. The top sale reached $3.2 million.

    Here is the honest part, because we only tell you what the data supports: these buyers did not overpay. The median Colony sale closed at 81.5% of the original asking price, down from 89.5% last fall. But against the final asking price, it was 93.5%.

    In plain terms: sellers who had started high adjusted their prices over the summer, and when the price was right, buyers showed up in force well before season. That is a healthy market, not a desperate one. It is what pent-up demand looks like when it finally meets realistic pricing.

    Tiburón: Naples buyers paid more per foot

    Tiburón, home to the Ritz-Carlton Golf Resort and two Greg Norman-designed courses, tells a stronger pricing story. All 10 fall closings were condominiums in its mid- and low-rise buildings, a market that barely moved a year ago.

    Buyers didn't just come back. They paid more for every square foot: $557, up from $509. Sellers collected a median 92.6% of their original asking price, up from 89.9%. Tiburón's 2026 sales ranged from $600,000 to $1.5 million, which puts a resort-style private golf address within reach of buyers who might assume Naples is out of range.

    The rest of Pelican Landing: the honest contrast

    Not every corner surged. Outside The Colony, Pelican Landing closed 11 homes this fall versus 18 last year, and at a lower median price. Last fall that group was mostly single-family homes (12 of 18). This fall it was mostly condominiums (7 of 11), so the lower median reflects what sold more than a drop in values.

    The takeaway is not that Pelican Landing cooled. It is that within one community, buyers concentrated sharply in its premium towers and estates. Buyers are not shopping for "a golf community" — they are shopping for a very specific address, and they are moving on it early.

    What this tells us about the season ahead

    1. Early buyers are getting the best selection. Buyers who acted in September and October chose from inventory before the winter crowd arrived.
    2. Pricing is the trigger. At The Colony, the gap between original and final asking price shows that sellers who repriced were the ones who sold.
    3. Condo confidence is returning in private clubs. 27 of the 37 fall closings were in mid- and high-rise buildings, up from 9 of 24 last year.

    If you are thinking about buying, the lesson is simple: don't assume the good homes will still be there in February. If you are thinking about selling, price for the market we have now, and you can sell before season even starts.

    How we did it

    We pulled every residential closed sale from the Southwest Florida MLS for two identical windows: September 18 – November 17, 2025, and September 18 – November 17, 2026. We matched sales to each community by the MLS community and subdivision names, kept only Naples addresses for Tiburón, and set aside sales under $50,000 so rentals and parking or boat-slip records were not counted. We grouped The Colony separately from the rest of Pelican Landing. Every median and total was computed directly from those records.

    Limits worth knowing: these are small counts, so one or two sales can move a median noticeably. Days on market are not recorded consistently in closed MLS data, so we don't report them. Sixty days is a snapshot, not a full-year trend.

    This is the kind of analysis our team runs every week: not headlines, but the actual closed records, sale by sale. If you want this level of detail for a community you are considering, call or text Julie at 239.238.7786 or email julie.borden@premiersir.com.

    Share

    Frequently Asked

    Frequently asked questions

    How many homes sold at The Colony at Pelican Landing this fall?
    16 homes closed between September 18 and November 17, 2026, compared with 3 in the same window of 2025. Sales volume rose from $4.1 million to $23.7 million.
    Are prices rising at Tiburón in Naples?
    Tiburón closed 10 condominiums in the fall 2026 window versus 3 a year earlier. The median price per square foot rose from $509 to $557, and sellers received a median 92.6% of their original asking price.
    How was this analysis done?
    The Julie Borden team compared every residential closed MLS sale in two identical 60-day windows (September 18 – November 17, 2025 and 2026), matched by MLS community and subdivision names, excluding sales under $50,000 to remove rentals.